Skip to main content

The Bagel Conflict and My Left Coast Bagels

When one of my blogging friends - Sue of Palatable Pastime - posted our #FoodieExtravaganza topic for December, I decided that I needed to try to conquer the bagel and gave myself plenty of practice time. So, I started reading and researching how to make bagels. That landed me on this question: Did you know that bagels were controversial? I didn't.

The Bagel Conflict

Back in 2017, one of my best friends made bagels and delivered some to my doorstep. My family was thrilled!

That same weekend I received my issue of Food & Wine magazine and there was an article about Montréal bagels. I texted Pia that she was on-trend! And I, clearly, am three years behind the wave. Ha.

Honestly, I probably still wouldn't have made bagels except that I am always up for a culinary adventure, especially if it's assigned for one of my blogging groups. Thanks, Sue. My family appreciates the nudge!

Okay, before I read that article in Food & Wine, I really had no idea that there was a conflict about bagels. New York bagels versus Montréal bagels and, then, the travesty that are bagels in California. I'm serious. There are stories - and very strong opinions - about that. Listen to the podcast from 2015 on KQED: Why You Can't Get a New York Bagel in California. Elizabeth Weil, contributing writer to New York Times Magazine who wrote Why Is It So Hard to Get a Great Bagel in California?

My Left Coast Bagels

Let's start with some basics...and some comparisons and contrasts. If we use the New York bagel as the standard, the Montréal bagel is thinner, sweeter, and denser, with a larger hole; it is also always baked in a wood-fired oven. Additionally, the Montréal bagel contains malt and egg and is boiled in a honey-sweetened water before being fired.

A word popped into my head that I haven't really used since I studied philosophy in college: tautological. Essentially it means that the statement is true in every possible form. What I mean is that you can not have a New York bagel in California. You just can't. You can have a New York-style bagel in California. But a bagel made in California is a California bagel by clear logic.

So I have set out to make a good Left Coast bagel that's dense and toothy. It's not a New York bagel or a Montréal bagel. It's just a bagel made in the classic California: I boiled them in water before baking. I've made these several times with a few variations. I assure you, they are flexible and worth every ounce of effort you put into them. I combined a few different bagel recipes to create this version.

Ingredients makes 8 bagels
  • 1 Tablespoon active dry yeast
  • 1 Tablespoon organic granulated sugar
  • 1-1/4 cup warm water plus more as needed
  • 3-1/4 cups flour plus more for kneading
  • 1 teaspoon salt (I used the Morada salt from Big Sur Salts that has elderberry, hibiscus, rose bud, and lemon peel)
  • black and white sesame seeds for topping, optional (feel free to experiment with whatever toppings you like)


Pour 1/2 cup warm water in a medium mixing bowl. Add in the sugar and the yeast. Let bloom for 5 to 10 minutes.

In a large mixing bowl, whisk together the flour and salt. Form a well in the center and pour in the yeast mixture. Add another 1/2 cup warm water to the well also. Use a wooden spoon to combine to form a stiff dough. You may need another 1/4 water if the dough is too stiff.

Turn the dough out onto a lightly floured countertop. Knead the dough until it is smooth an elastic, approximately 10 minutes.

Oil a large mixing bowl and place the dough inside, rolling it over so that every surface of your ball is covered. Cover the bowl with a damp towel and let rise in a warm place for 1 hour or until the dough has doubled in size. Punch the dough down, then let it rest for another 10 minutes.

After the dough has rested for a second time, divide the dough into 8 pieces. I am not that precise, so they are uneven. But you can weigh them if you wish. 

Roll the dough into a ball. Press your thumb into the center of each dough ball to form a ring. Gently stretch the ring to about a third of the diameter of the bagel. Place the bagel on a parchment paper-lined baking sheet. Repeat with all the dough until you have eight bagels.

After shaping the dough let them rest while you bring a large pot of water to a boil and preheat your oven to  425 degrees Fahrenheit.

Once the water has come to a rolling boil, lower the bagels into the water. Don't crowd them; I usually do four at a time. Boil the bagels for 2 minutes before flipping them over and boiling them for another 2 minutes.

Place them back on the baking sheet and sprinkle them with whatever topping you desire. I used black and white sesame seeds for this batch. Put the tray in the oven until the bagels are golden brown, approximately 20 to 25 minutes.

Cool on a wire rack for 5 to 10 minutes before slicing. Enjoy!


  1. Great story! Did you know that Montreal is considering banning wood fired ovens? Everyone in the Montreal bagel community is beside themselves. Then there's the controversy as to whether or not you poke a hole or form them into logs and join the ends, lol!

    1. I hadn't read about that poke-the-hole controversy. Who knew?!


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Meyer Lemon Custard-Filled Matcha Turtles #BreadBakers

#BreadBakers is a group of bread loving bakers who get together once a month to bake bread with a common ingredient or theme. You can see all our of lovely bread by following our  Pinterest board  right here. Links are also updated after each event on the  Bread Bakers home page .  We take turns hosting each month and choosing the theme/ingredient. This month Stacy of Food Lust People Love  is hosting and she wrote: "Your bread can be large, as in one big animal, or small - animal-shaped rolls. Use your imagination! Points for flavor and shape!" If you are a food blogger and would like to join us, just send an email with your blog URL to Stacy at Here's the animal-shaped bread basket from the #BreadBakers... Beef and Sweet Onion Dim Sum Pandas from Karen's Kitchen Stories Bird Bread Rolls from Ambrosia Easter Bunny Buns from Cook with Renu Ham and Cheese Elephant Rolls from Food Lust People Love Hedgehog Bread from Making Mir

Connecticut Lobster Rolls, Canned Lobster Bisque, and a 2019 Henry Fessy 'Maître Bonhome' Viré-Clessé #Winophiles

This month the French Winophiles group is looking at affordable wines from Burgundy.  Host Cindy of Grape Experiences wrote: "Burgundy, or Bourgogne, is known for its wines of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir... as well as Aligote, Gamay, Sauvignon, César, Pinot Beurot, Sacy, Melon in lesser quantities. Many of the well-known wines are quite expensive, but there are plenty of values to be found." Read her invitation here. And there won't be a Twitter chat for this event, so you will have to dive into the articles themselves to read about our pairings and findings. Here's the line-up... Wendy Klik from A Day in the Life on the Farm enjoys Domaine Chevillon Chezeaux Bourgogne Hautes Cotes de Nuits, 2018 Paired with a Maple Pecan Chicken . Camilla Mann from Culinary Adventures with Camilla shares her love of Connecticut Lobster Rolls, Canned Lobster Bisque, and a 2019 Henry Fessy 'Maître Bonhome' Viré-Clessé. Jeff Burrows of FoodWineClick! explains why we should Look t

Quick Pickled Red Onions and Radishes

If you've been reading my blog for even a short amount of time, you probably know how much I love to pickle things. I was just telling a friend you can pickle - with vinegar - or you can ferment - with salt - for similar delicious effect. The latter has digestive benefits and I love to do that, but when I need that pop of sour flavor quickly, I whip up quick pickles that are ready in as little as a day or two. I've Pickled Blueberries , Pickled Asparagus , Pickled Cranberries , Pickled Pumpkin , and even Pickled Chard Stems ! This I did last night for an upcoming recipe challenge that requires I include radishes. Ummmm...of course I'm pickling them! Ingredients  makes 1 quart jar radishes, trimmed and sliced organic red onions, peeled and thinly sliced (I used a mandolin slicer) 3/4 C vinegar (I used white distilled vinegar) 3/4 C water 3 T organic granulated sugar 1 T salt (I used some grey sea salt) 6 to 8 grinds of black pepper Proce