Skip to main content

A Blind Tasting: Corn-Fed vs. Grass-Fed Beef


If you've read Michael Pollan's The Omnivore Dilemma, you likely have an opinion about corn-fed versus grass-fed beef. I certainly do. I read the book years ago and no other has affected my food purchases more; it was even assigned reading in my 5th grader's class this year. It's no surprise that food choices, environmental impact, and nutritional concerns are hot topics of conversation around my dinner table.

In any case, Pollan's book caused me to re-think my beef purchases and I have, as much as possible, switched completely over to organic and 100% grass-fed. There are distinctions between grass-finished and grass-fed, but that is for another blogpost.

A good friend of mine raises cattle in Ohio. Corn-fed. He and I have talked about what is most important, for me, as an informed consumer, in purchasing beef. Will I buy organic before grass-fed? He was weighing the benefits of switching to organic corn; apparently, there is virtually no market for grass-fed beef in his part of the United States. I was honest: As a rule, I don't buy corn-fed beef. Ever.

He asked if I would do a tasting, if he sent me some. I am relatively open-minded (don't laugh, Richard!) and agreed. So, I roped in two other families and did a blind tasting with Mumford Farm corn-fed beef and Panorama organic, 100% grass-fed beef.

What we ate...
I used the ground beef to make Swedish meatballs. [recipe to come]


And we had grilled porterhouse with whiskey mushrooms. [recipe to come]


What we thought...
I found the results surprising. I really don't know what Richard was anticipating our response to be. We'll see.


Across the board, the comments about texture were definitive: the grassfed, both meatballs and porterhouse, was more dry. "Dryer [sic], smaller," wrote one little taste-tester. "Juicyer [sic], bigger, tender," he commented on the corn-fed. " Other comments mirrored those sentiments - more moist, moister, oily, amazing texture.

But the comments about the flavor ran the gamut. The adults were all over the place. One adult wrote that the grass-fed meatballs were "milder in flavor" while another commented "slightly gamier" about the grass-fed. "Moister, more flavorful," came up on the porterhouse tasting notes about the corn-fed. "Sweeter" was also a descriptor. Strangely, all five of the kids, probably because that's what we buy, gravitated toward the grass-fed in taste. They are accustomed to it.

What does it all mean...
Corn-fed beef is more moist. No doubt about that. But, regarding flavor, it's a matter of preference. Corn-fed is more mild. Grass-fed is, well, grassier; it's gamier and stronger in taste.

I, myself, love the grassiness and can work on texture based on preparation. But I will readily admit that the corn-fed beef was more delicate, in texture, and more sweet, in taste.

So, will this exercise change how I buy beef? No, not at all. There are still the impacts on the environment and the cows themselves to consider. But I really appreciated the opportunity to do a blind, side-by-side tasting. Thanks, Mumford Farm!

Comments

  1. Glad to see you were open to trying corn-fed. I would've sent some different cuts out as well if I would've known! :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I, too, loved Michael's book. It was his book, along with others, that made me decide to grow my own chicken, turkey and pork. I buy my beef from a friend who raises them on grass with some supplemental corn. She describes it as if we humans eat mostly fruits and vegetables as we should but sometimes splurge on dessert. That is how she figures it is with her cows. 80% grass fed and 20% corn or dessert. Her beef is delicious and that explanation sounded reasonable to me.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very interesting results to read! Thank you for sharing - love the shared tasting notes. :)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Connecticut Lobster Rolls, Canned Lobster Bisque, and a 2019 Henry Fessy 'MaƮtre Bonhome' VirƩ-ClessƩ #Winophiles

This month the French Winophiles group is looking at affordable wines from Burgundy.  Host Cindy of Grape Experiences wrote: "Burgundy, or Bourgogne, is known for its wines of Chardonnay and Pinot Noir... as well as Aligote, Gamay, Sauvignon, CĆ©sar, Pinot Beurot, Sacy, Melon in lesser quantities. Many of the well-known wines are quite expensive, but there are plenty of values to be found." Read her invitation here. And there won't be a Twitter chat for this event, so you will have to dive into the articles themselves to read about our pairings and findings. Here's the line-up... Wendy Klik from A Day in the Life on the Farm enjoys Domaine Chevillon Chezeaux Bourgogne Hautes Cotes de Nuits, 2018 Paired with a Maple Pecan Chicken . Camilla Mann from Culinary Adventures with Camilla shares her love of Connecticut Lobster Rolls, Canned Lobster Bisque, and a 2019 Henry Fessy 'MaĆ®tre Bonhome' VirĆ©-ClessĆ©. Jeff Burrows of FoodWineClick! explains why we should Look t

Meyer Lemon Custard-Filled Matcha Turtles #BreadBakers

#BreadBakers is a group of bread loving bakers who get together once a month to bake bread with a common ingredient or theme. You can see all our of lovely bread by following our  Pinterest board  right here. Links are also updated after each event on the  Bread Bakers home page .  We take turns hosting each month and choosing the theme/ingredient. This month Stacy of Food Lust People Love  is hosting and she wrote: "Your bread can be large, as in one big animal, or small - animal-shaped rolls. Use your imagination! Points for flavor and shape!" If you are a food blogger and would like to join us, just send an email with your blog URL to Stacy at foodlustpeoplelove@gmail.com. Here's the animal-shaped bread basket from the #BreadBakers... Beef and Sweet Onion Dim Sum Pandas from Karen's Kitchen Stories Bird Bread Rolls from Ambrosia Easter Bunny Buns from Cook with Renu Ham and Cheese Elephant Rolls from Food Lust People Love Hedgehog Bread from Making Mir

Homemade Lorna Doone Cookies #SundayFunday

Today the Sunday Funday group is celebrating childhood favorites. Thanks to Stacy of  Food Lust People Love , Sue of  Palatable Pastime , Rebekah of  Making Miracles , and Wendy of  A Day in the Life on the Farm  for coordinating this low-stress group. Today Stacy is hosting and she's given us the following prompt: "Childhood favorites. Did you have a favorite dish growing up? It could be something your family cooked or a restaurant dish, even a Chef Boyardee canned good or packaged ingredients like Rice-a Roni or mac and cheese. Recreate THAT dish from SCRATCH for this event."  Here's the #SundayFunday childhood favorites line-up... Chili Mac from A Day in the Life on the Farm Ham and Mushroom Breakfast Burritos from Making Miracles Homemade Lorna Doone Cookies from Culinary Adventures with Camilla Homemade Wonder Bread from Karen's Kitchen Stories K-Mart Sub Sandwiches from Palatable Pastime Kempakki Dosa from Sizzling Tastebuds Meat Chilly Fry by Sn