Well, Dylan's Eyes of Newt were his pickled green tomatoes and they can't be done on the fly. Sorry. Click for the recipe: Green Tomato Pickles. And, next year, give yourself at least a month lead-time to make these. They were a hit!
My 'Skewered Cyclops Eyeballs' were mini-skewers of mini-heirloom tomatoes and ciliegie. I forgot to pack the fresh basil. Whoops.
Super duper easy...and fittingly festive. Happy Halloween!